Ophthalmology

National Recruitment ST1 up to 90

Portfolio Review

Paper Portfolio - List of Contents

All candidates will be asked to bring a paper portfolio with them to the interviews.  It is important to follow the list of contents precisely as marks may be deducted for including unnecessary information. Please file the information under the headings and strictly in the order listed. Please make an index and mark the sections clearly.

All documentation must be supplied within the portfolio, including copies of certificates.  No original certificates need to be provided in the portfolio unless they fit into the A4 portfolio format. Clear A4 copies of the certificates are acceptable.

Please ensure there is no patient identifiable documentation included within the portfolio of evidence.

Guidelines

List of Previous posts

Please include a list of all your previous posts (your most recent post first).  If you are not currently working within a clinical post please specify.

Education

Qualifications with certificates or letter of proof

CUMULATIVE SCORING (Maximum 4 points)

1 point - per qualification - Intercalated degree, MSc, BA (Any subject including Oxbridge), BSc (including Optom)

2 points- for an MD thesis

3 points - for a completed PhD or DPhil

Prizes/Awards

with proof

 CUMULATIVE SCORING (Maximum 5 points)

1 point - 1st in undergraduate degree

1 point - for Best paper or poster at a national meeting, successful research grant application.

2 points – for Best paper or presentation at international meeting, Crombe Medal (stood 1st in FRCOphth 1)

National Undergraduate prize (in any specialty) e.g. The Duke Elder prize

-      2 points for coming in top 10% of entrants.

-      1 point for being in the top 60%. (or a pass in 2016 or earlier exam sittings)

Training & Experience

Ophthalmology specialty links and commitment to date as a career

CUMULATIVE SCORING (Maximum 12 points)

1 point for each piece of evidence indicating commitment to speciality & non Peer review research

For example: elective ophthalmic project during undergraduate career, maintenance of links with speciality e.g. attending eye casualty/dept regularly in free time,  taster week in ophthalmology, microsurgical skills  course undertaken, evidence of EyeSi assessments, published case reports or letters, any publications in non-peer review journals e.g. British Undergraduate Journal of Ophthalmology, presentations at undergraduate meetings.

2 points: Refraction Certificate

3 points: FRCOphth part 1

4 points (max): Non peer reviewed publications & case reports (Only if first author otherwise no points awarded)

1 point (max): Ophthalmic elective/project

1 point (max): Taster week

3 points (max): Meetings attended - National / International Ophthalmology Courses or meetings attended: 2 points max (1 point per meeting / course) Regional Ophthalmology meetings attended (0.5 point per meeting):1 point max EyeSi assessments (minimum 4 hours min : 1 point max    Attending Eye clinic and theatre sessions (minimum 10 sessions with dates & signed evidence): 1 point max

Multi-Source Feedback

(MSF)

(Maximum 5 points)

The MSF must have been taken place within 18 months of the interview date.

Candidates not currently within a clinical post who do not have an MSF within the timeframe (e.g. undertaking a longer period of research or an extended period of leave) should include the MSF from their most recent clinical post.

The MSF should include feedback from a minimum of 5 respondents if in a general practice post or 7 respondents if in a hospital post.  Your educational supervisor or equivalent supervisor should collate this information and summarise it in a report. The report should include the period the MSF covered.  

The report must be signed by the educational supervisor or department lead and stamped with a departmental stamp.  If including a standard Team Assessment Behaviour Form (TAB) printed from E-portfolio it does not require a signature or departmental stamp.

For candidates without access to an on-line portfolio or unfamiliar with the MSF process information can be accessed from the link below.

Click for:  Multi Source Feedback Guidance 

 

 

 

 

 

Audit, Research & Teaching

Publications

(Maximum score 10 points)

List of publications (preferably from a PubMed Author search) with a photocopy of the first page (original articles or studies). No marks will be given without a copy of the first page of published paper or evidence of accepted paper.

Please also complete a proforma for your publication(s).  A sample of the proforma is below and the actual proforma to be used is available on the recruitment website.  

On the proforma list each journal, the impact factor for each and whether you were 1st, 2nd, 3rd or 4th or > author.  The proforma will be retained by the central recruitment team for purposes of verification.

Click for:  Site for Impact factor

Click for:  Proforma

Quality improvement / Audit projects

(Maximum score 5 points)

Copy of your best QI project or audit, performed within the last 3 years of the interview date, with a short summary of your role in the project / audit.  The audit should have standards, outcomes, recommendations and signed by the supervising consultant.

Notes: covering letter or certificate are necessary for proof of presentation

Audit, Research & Teaching

Presentations

CUMULATIVE SCORING (Maximum score 6 Points)

List of presentations and copies of abstracts or posters, stating whether it is a poster presentation or oral presentation..  Proof through abstract book or signed letter from supervisor

For example;

1 Point - Regional presentations (signed by training organiser) SOC, SWOS

2 Points - National presentations (For example British Oculoplastic Surgery Society, British and Eire Association of Vitreo Retinal Surgeons, or other specialty equivalents in the UK or national ophthalmology meetings of other countries or equivalent non-ophthalmology meetings) 

3 Points - International meetings – For example Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology, American Academy of Ophthalmology, RCOphth Congress etc or equivalent non-ophthalmology meetings. 

NB: The same paper presented at different meetings will only be counted once e.g. the highest ranking meeting.

Education and Teaching

CUMULATIVE SCORING (Maximum Score 5 Points)

For example;

Designing an educational course or e-learning tool, completing a teaching the teachers course, formal role in examining undergraduates

Writing a chapter in a textbook, Writing a book, Higher teaching qualification such as a Diploma, Certificate or Masters in Medical education

All must come with supporting evidence.

Overall portfolio layout & quality

Global quality & presentation

(Maximum Score 3 Points)

Layout, organisation and quality of how it is presented will be assessed.

Guide to the size of an ideal paper portfolio:

The evidence for each item must be as per instructions to candidates. No marks if incorrect or no evidence submitted

 


Sample 

Portfolio - Publication Proforma

Please complete the attached proforma for your publication(s).  List each journal, the impact factor and a score for which author you were.

Please multiply the impact factor by your author’s score and then add the total score at the bottom of the table.

  • 4 points – 1st author
  • 3 points – 2nd author
  • 2 points – 3rd author
  • 1 point – 4th or later author

Name of Journal

Impact Factor

Score for authorship

Impact Factor x Score

Example – European Journal of Ophthalmology

2.81

2

5.6

Example – UK Journal of Orthopaedics

0.62

4

2.5

 

 

 

 

Total Score   

8.1